Circuitmart Logo The Electronics Assembly Network Newsletter Subscription
Home Board Talk Ask the Experts Mysteries of Science Talk Back Tech Papers Trends for Tomorrow Marketplace Sponsors Search
Board Talk

At Board Talk, the Assembly Brothers cut through the marketing hype, the platitudes and incompetent un-scientific baloney with a search for the truth.
This episode features:

Phil Zarrow Phil Zarrow, ITM Consulting
Phil has been involved with hybrid and PCB assembly for more than 30 years including equipment design for pcb fab and assembly.

Jim Hall Jim Hall, ITM Consulting
Jim has a wealth of knowledge in soldering and thermal technology, equipment and process basics and is a pioneer in the science of reflow technology.
What's happening at SMTA International?
SMTAI Promo
Meet Phil Zarrow and Jim Hall of ITM Consulting at SMTA International.
Oct 24: The Deadly Sins of SMT and Lead-Free Assembly
Oct 25: Advanced SMT Manufacturing
Learn More ...
Rework Lead-Free Boards with Leaded Solder

Rework Lead-Free Boards with Leaded Solder
Can boards built with lead-free be reworked with leaded solder? I realize they may not comply with RoHS, but will they be reliable?
Views: 2046


Comments
Situation: In house repair facility for boards from various vendors. A board may bear a ROHS label, but the lead free solder alloy is not known.

What is the best rework procedure? Clean off original solder residue first, or just use any lead free alloy and not worry about the resulting mix?

J.M.



In your "board talk" concerning repairing lead-free joints with tin-lead, I believe you said, in-part, "If the board is used in a high stress environment then the tin-lead is more reliable but if its a low-stress environment then the lead free repair is more reliable".

If I heard you correctly, could you educate me brifly as to why? I would have thought the repair best suited for a high-stress environment would always be more reliable in any situation. What am I missing here?

B.S.




Related Programs All Related Programs

Is There A Thermal Cycle Limit?
Board Talk
Is Pre-Bake Standard for Rework?
Ask the Experts
Recommended Rework Dwell Times
Ask the Experts
Reliability Assessment of Reballed BGAs
Tech Papers
BGA Replacement Limit
Ask the Experts

Submit a Comment

Advertise  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms & Conditions 

CircuitMart - A Circuitnet Publication   |   22 Parkridge Road, Haverhill MA 01835 USA   |   Copyright 2009 © All rights reserved.